Most roundups of the top Halloween deals list discounts and stop there. That is only half the decision, because a 30% discount today and a 70% discount in eleven days are the same shelf.
So this one sorts every category into three columns. Buy it now, wait, or do not bother at all.
The Short Answer
|
Category |
Right now |
Why |
|---|---|---|
|
Candy |
Buy |
Prices rising, not falling |
|
Costumes |
Buy |
Sizes gone by week's end |
|
Indoor decor |
Wait |
70% off arrives 1 November |
|
Outdoor inflatables |
Wait |
Same cliff, bigger saving |
|
Greeting cards |
Skip |
Cheapest line, lowest need |
Candy and costumes now. Decorations later. Cards never.
The split is not about depth of discount. It is about whether the thing you want will still exist, and in your size, when the discount gets deeper.
Costumes run out. Decorations do not, at least not in any way that matters, because the box you store them in opens again next October and the inflatable will not have aged.
Where Americans Actually Spend

|
Where the money goes |
Total |
Share |
Per buyer |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Costumes |
$4.4bn |
32.6% |
$52.86 |
|
Decorations |
$4.3bn |
31.9% |
$47.02 |
|
Candy |
$4.1bn |
30.4% |
$36.43 |
|
Greeting cards |
$0.8bn |
5.9% |
$16.25 |
|
All of it |
$13.5bn |
100% |
$115.14 |
$13.5 billion in total, and the per buyer column is ours.
A retail trade body's survey of 7,889 people puts total spending at $13.5 billion this year against a record $13.1 billion last year, which is a rise of 3.1%, with 74% of people celebrating and an average of $115.14 each.
Divide the total by that average and you get roughly 117.2 million people spending. We used that figure to work out what each category costs per actual buyer, which the survey does not publish, and the result reorders everything.
Halloween candy has the most buyers by far at 96%, but the lowest spend per buyer at $36.43. Halloween decorations have fewer buyers at 78% and a per buyer spend of $47.02, which is 29.1% higher. Costume buyers spend $52.86, or 45.1% more than candy buyers.
In other words, candy is what everyone buys and decor is where the money is. That is exactly why the clearance pattern works the way it does.
Candy: Buy It, the Price Is Going Up

|
The candy numbers |
Figure |
|---|---|
|
100 piece bag, now |
$16.96 |
|
Up on last year |
3.5%, about $0.59 |
|
Up since 2021 |
71% |
|
Up 2020 to 2025 |
78% |
|
Same budget buys |
40% less than 2020 |
|
Per piece, 100 bag |
$0.1696 |
$16.96 for a 100 piece bag, up 71% since 2021.
This is the one category where waiting costs you. A 100 piece bag now averages $16.96, up 3.5% on last year, which is about 59 cents, and up 71% since 2021.
A separate analysis cited in the same report put the rise from 2020 to 2025 at 78%, and another found the same budget buys 40% less candy than it did in 2020.
One thing we will flag rather than smooth over. The same report says wholesale cocoa prices are down 70%, while a financial strategist quoted in it says supply is about 16% lower and chocolate is up 11% to 12%. Those two statements sit awkwardly together, we cannot reconcile them, and we are reporting both.
The Pack Size Trick
|
Pack size is the whole game |
Cost per piece |
|---|---|
|
100 piece variety bag at $16.96 |
$0.1696 |
|
55 count Reese's Pieces at $29 |
$0.5273 |
|
The gap |
210.9% more per piece |
|
What that means |
Branded small packs cost triple |
Per piece, small branded packs cost 210.9% more.
Here is the arithmetic that actually saves money, and nobody prints it on the shelf.
That $16.96 bag works out at $0.1696 per piece. A 55 count bag of a named branded candy at $29 works out at $0.5273 per piece, which is 210.9% more for each thing you hand a child at the door.
Children at the door do not audit brands. They count pieces. Buy the large variety bag for the door and keep one branded pack for the house if you want it.
-
Work out cost per piece, not per bag
-
Variety bags beat single brand packs
-
Chocolate rose more than gummies and hard candy
-
Store coupons and rebates stack on candy
Costumes: Buy Now, Sizes Are the Constraint

|
Costume spend |
Total |
Share of costumes |
|---|---|---|
|
Adults |
$2.0bn |
45.5% |
|
Children |
$1.5bn |
34.1% |
|
Pets |
$0.92bn |
20.9% |
|
All costumes |
$4.4bn |
100% |
$4.4 billion in total, and one costume dollar in five is spent on an animal.
Costumes are the biggest single line at $4.4 billion, which is 32.6% of all Halloween spending. Adults account for $2.0 billion against $1.5 billion for children, so grown ups outspend their kids by 33.3%.
Pets take $0.92 billion, which is 20.9% of all costume money. One costume dollar in five is being spent on an animal that did not ask for this.
Buy now, because costume discount codes do get deeper in the last week but the stock that remains is whatever nobody wanted. A 60% discount on the wrong size is not a deal.
Live Deals We Checked
|
Live examples we checked |
Sale |
Was |
Off |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Trunk or treat kit |
$13.50 |
$36.99 |
64% |
|
Inflatable kids costume |
$11.19 |
$31.99 |
65% |
|
Light up ghost decor |
$12.59 |
$26.99 |
53% |
|
Skull hand towels, two |
$7.50 |
$14.99 |
50% |
|
M&M's two pack |
$12.26 |
$19.99 |
39% |
|
Halloween fairy lights |
$3.99 |
$6.99 |
43% |
Real listings on the day we looked, between 39% and 65% off.
These came off a deals tracking site on the day of writing, with the discounts exactly as that site listed them, and they give a fair sense of what a genuine Halloween discount looks like this week rather than what a banner claims. None of them is a doorbuster. All of them are real.
The pattern worth noticing is that costumes and novelty items are already at 50% to 65% off, which is close to where they will land. Halloween decorations in that same list sit at 43% to 53%, well short of where they are heading.
The 1 November Cliff
|
Retailer |
When it cuts |
How deep |
|---|---|---|
|
Lowe's |
Before Halloween |
50%, then up to 75% |
|
Big Lots |
Mid October |
20%, then about 50% |
|
Target |
Last 7 days, then 1 Nov |
Up to 30%, then 70% |
|
Walmart |
1 November |
50%, then 70% in 3 to 4 days |
|
Big Lots again |
By Veterans Day |
Often about 90% |
Target goes to 70% the day after. Lowe's cuts before Halloween instead.
There is no single national schedule. Halloween clearance varies by chain, and the differences between chains are large enough to plan around.
One retailer cuts up to 30% in the final seven days then drops to 70% off on 1 November. Another starts Halloween clearance on 1 November at 50% and reaches 70% three or four days later. A home improvement chain marks down about two weeks out at 50% and up to 75% close to the day, because it wants the floor space before November. A closeout chain starts mid October around 20%, drops to roughly 50% after the day, and is often near 90% by Veterans Day.
We should say plainly that this schedule comes from a guide last updated in 2023, so treat it as the shape of the pattern rather than a promise for any particular store this year.
What Waiting Is Actually Worth
|
$100 of decorations costs |
You pay |
|---|---|
|
At full price |
$100.00 |
|
At 30% off, late October |
$70.00 |
|
At 70% off, 1 November |
$30.00 |
|
At 90% off, mid November |
$10.00 |
|
Waiting one week saves |
57.1% against the 30% price |
$100 of decor becomes $30 on 1 November and $10 by mid November.
Put a number on patience. A hundred dollars of decorations costs $70 at a 30% late October markdown and $30 at a 70% markdown on 1 November.
That is 57.1% less, for waiting about one week. At the 90% clearance some chains reach by mid November it is $10, though by then you are buying whatever survived.
The catch is obvious and we will say it anyway. None of this decorates your house this year. It is a purchase for next October, stored in a box, and it is the single biggest saving available in the entire Halloween calendar.
The Verdict
|
Category |
Verdict |
|---|---|
|
Candy Deals |
Buy now |
|
Costume Deals |
Buy now |
|
Decoration Deals |
Wait for 1 November |
|
Greeting Cards |
Skip |
|
Best Single Saving |
Next year's decor, bought next week |
Buy the consumables now and the durables in November. The top Halloween deals this week are genuinely good on costumes and novelty items at 50% to 65% off, and candy is worth buying today because its price is rising rather than falling, with the large variety bag beating small branded packs by 210.9% per piece. Halloween decorations are the opposite case. Anything that goes back in a box is 70% off within eleven days and sometimes 90% within three weeks, so buying it now at 40% off is paying roughly double for the privilege of eleven days of use. Greeting cards are the smallest line at 5.9% of spending and the easiest thing to drop.
FAQs
When do the best Halloween deals actually land?
For costumes and candy, the last two weeks of October. For decorations, 1 November, when several chains move straight to 70% off.
Should I buy Halloween decorations now?
Only if you need them for this year. If you are stocking up, waiting until 1 November cuts a $100 basket to about $30.
Why is Halloween candy more expensive this year?
A 100 piece bag is up 3.5% on last year and 71% since 2021. Reports cite cocoa supply, transport, packaging and tariffs, though the figures quoted do not fully agree.
What is the cheapest way to buy Halloween candy?
Large variety bags. At $16.96 for 100 pieces the cost is $0.1696 each, against $0.5273 for a 55 count branded bag.
Which store has the best Halloween clearance?
It varies by chain. One home improvement retailer cuts up to 75% before Halloween, while discount chains go deepest after it, reaching about 90% by mid November.
How much does the average person spend?
$115.14, against $114.45 last year, with 74% of people taking part and total spending of $13.5 billion.
We have not bought any of the products listed and this article compares published information rather than items we tested. Spending totals, participation rates, category splits and the per person average come from a named retail trade body's survey of 7,889 consumers conducted in early September, with a stated margin of error of plus or minus 1.1 percentage points. Candy pricing, the cocoa claims and the inflation comparisons are quoted from a news report published on the day of writing, which itself cited several third party analyses, and those sources did not fully agree with each other, which we have reported rather than resolved. The clearance schedule comes from a retail guide last updated in 2023 and should be treated as a pattern rather than a guarantee. Live sale prices were listed on a named deals tracking site on the day we checked and will have changed since. The number of celebrating shoppers, every per buyer figure, every per piece cost and all percentage comparisons are our own arithmetic derived from the published totals. Check current prices, stock and store policies before buying.
